In September 2008, Dr. Esam Beshay and his young family arrived in Canada on a holiday, touching down in Winnipeg where his sister-in-law had resided since 2003.
The then-33-year-old dentist had operated his own private practice in Egypt for seven years – and he was taken by his visit to our country. But when the family immigrated here in 2010, Dr. Beshay quickly learned that becoming certified as a dentist in his adopted home was going to be a costly and daunting proposition.
“It’s not easy – the exams and the equipment cost thousands of dollars. And I need to take time off work to prepare for the tests,” explained Dr. Beshay in 2012. “And, still, I need to feed my family of four. Believe me, it’s a long, long journey.” He described how he took on other work to provide for his family, realizing that it would be years before he could save the money he needed to pursue his true calling.
Dr. Beshay’s comments were made in a video depicting how he had just received a loan via a two-year pilot program administered by Winnipeg’s Assiniboine Credit Union (110,000 members, $3.6 billion in assets). Called Recognition Counts!™, the program grants five-year micro-loans of up to $10,000 to low-income, skilled immigrants looking to put their expertise to use in Manitoba but who can’t afford the expense of meeting re-accreditation and training requirements. The timing was excellent for Dr. Beshay. Within three months of receiving the loan, he’d passed all his tests and found work in a busy dental clinic. By March 2014, the motivated dentist had opened his own office in downtown Winnipeg, where today he employs a staff of five.
Boosting skilled immigrants
Recognition Counts!, a partnership between Assiniboine, SEED Winnipeg (a local non-profit organization), the federal government and the province, is a solid example of a targeted program that engages a specific immigrant population by meeting its needs. Although the project has operated for just two years, 120 people have already gone through the program, with 12 repaying their loans in full, long before the five years everyone is given. In the process, the newcomers it has helped are drawn into the credit union fold.
“When these folks do become successful, in terms of material success, we are confident that they will come to us as the organization that supported them and helped them get their start,” explains Nigel Mohammed, director of the Community Financial Centre at Assiniboine.
While the future of the two-year pilot is uncertain, Mohammed believes it should – and will – continue. “The people going through this program are all experts in professions that are underrepresented in Winnipeg – nurses, engineers, doctors,” he says. “These folks shouldn’t be working in jobs that are far below their credentials. They should be engaged and helping to drive our economy.”
Similar micro-loan programs are being operated in British Columbia, Ontario, Quebec and New Brunswick, with forward-looking credit unions teaming up with partner organizations to ensure that skilled immigrants have the opportunity to thrive in their fields.
This type of innovative thinking and programming is something Credit Union Central of Canada is committed to encouraging. That’s why it partnered with the Filene Research Institute to commission Financial Services Needs of Immigrant Communities in Canada and the United States, released in 2013. Researching the topic was likely overdue. After all, we’re a nation of immigrants, with more than 20 per cent of us foreign born. About 250,000 immigrants make their way to Canada every year, drawn by the economic and educational opportunities. And if demographic trends continue, the report notes, most of the future population growth in Canada will come from immigrants and their children. With that in mind, the report focuses on the challenges and nuances of serving immigrant communities.
Parsing the findings
In commissioning the report, Canadian Central hopes that credit unions across the country will use the demographic overview to target their programs and strategize about novel ways to reach out to new Canadians. “Banks are moving into this area, so we need to be on our toes, perhaps taking more niche approaches and being more creative,” says Canadian Central’s Marc-André Pigeon, director of financial sector policy.
Creating an innovative product like the Recognition Counts! loan is one substantial way for a credit union to differentiate itself from the competition. But the report also notes that investment in immigrants is long term in nature. Average income levels for newcomers remain low for their first few years in the country, so products, it suggests, should initially be geared to meeting basic financial needs and increase in complexity as time goes on.
As well, although the report acknowledges that the immigrant market is obviously “highly diverse, with vast differences in culture and tradition,” it adds that certain constants do stand out. “Immigrants are hardworking (they are more likely to be in the labour force) and family-oriented (many households have more than two income earners),” say the authors. “[T]hey place a high value on both home ownership and education. They are also more likely to venture into self-employment.” That means many immigrants will be looking for small business loans, education loans and remittances.
The report suggests credit unions target marketing material in the native languages of immigrants, an approach that’s viable in larger cities with sizeable new populations from specific regions. Partnering with non-profit organizations is also recommended because it provides “exposure for the credit union and funding or services that could not otherwise be offered by the non-profit.” In the case of the Recognition Counts! program, loan applications are channeled through eight partners that include immigrant referral services and professional bodies such as engineering associations.
Making credit unions more welcoming is another key strategy. Multilingual services, extended business hours, brochures in multiple languages and community partnerships all go a long way to putting new immigrants at ease. Two banks have already figured some of this out, according to the report. HSBC now has almost all its Vancouver branches located in neighbourhoods where the Asian population is greater than 25 per cent. Meanwhile, Scotiabank recently opened a branch with extended business hours in Montreal’s busiest subway station, on the theory that immigrants are more likely to work irregular hours and are twice as likely to take public transportation.
Providing a helping hand
But for-profit financial institutions would never venture where Vancity (501,000 members, $17.5 billion in assets) has gone. It has committed a grant of $1 million toward a large-scale facility for refugees. Scheduled to open later in 2015, Welcome House Centre will have 200 beds and will include a child care centre, a youth centre, a medical clinic, education services, trauma support, government offices and a Vancity banking kiosk. Vancity staff will guide refugees in setting up their accounts and provide on-site workshops on financial literacy.
“When government-assisted refugees arrive, the only ID they have are their one-way travel journey documents,” explained Vancity community investment manager, Catherine Ludgate, in a press release launching the scheme. “Without ID, they aren’t bankable. After Immigrant Services Society of BC (ISSofBC) approached us with the problem, we worked with them on an alternative ID acceptance process. Now refugees are able to open bank accounts with us within the first two weeks of their arrival in Canada.” That’s important: research has shown that immigrants overwhelmingly remain with the financial institution where they first open an account.
Making the most of insider knowledge
It helps to understand the government’s immigration policies, too. In Canada, some 66 per cent of immigrants meet the criteria of the federal government’s so-called economic class – that is, they get permanent residency because they will likely contribute to a strong and prosperous Canadian economy. Another 21 per cent arrive under the family class, which aims to reunite relatives. A further nine per cent come here as refugees. These groupings can help guide how credit unions pursue opportunity, selecting target markets to focus on based on immigration patterns in their region. The Filene report says it’s essential to communicate “in a way that resonates” with the freshly arrived.
It helps if members of your staff can speak the same language as immigrants. To that end, in 2004 Assiniboine Credit Union and Cambrian Credit Union (110,000 members, $3 billion in assets) launched the Immigration Integration Program in Manitoba. Its goal: to help new Canadians find employment in the financial services sector. The program also makes the participating credit unions more diverse, allowing them to build relationships within a range of immigrant communities. Eleven years later, a total of five credit unions have come onboard to offer the 16-week paid practicum. The others are Steinbach Credit Union (80,700 members, $4.2 billion in assets), Portage Credit Union (9,000 members, $245 million in assets) and Westoba Credit Union (37,600 members, $1.2 billion in assets).
The program works like this: each year, about 10 candidates are selected. For the first four weeks, they take part in intensive training that introduces them to Canadian culture and the Canadian banking system. Over the next 12 weeks, they work full time at one of the credit union partners, learning the ropes as customer service representatives. “It’s an incredible program,” says Cherie Gebhardt, employment specialist with Assiniboine. “It’s beneficial to both the participant and the credit union. They gain experience in the financial sector and they help us understand their cultural community so we can meet that community’s banking needs.”
Gebhardt, who has taken the lead on the program for the past decade, says it has become so well-known – both through its longevity and success – that the screening process has become quite demanding. “We get people emailing us before they even arrive in Canada,” she says, adding that over the years most graduates have stayed with the credit unions they joined. In this way, the participating credit unions cement ties with their communities and bring a diversity of ideas to the table.
Flexibility pays big dividends
While all credit unions are adept at providing business loans, some are now breaking down their offerings to better accommodate the needs of immigrants. The Filene report notes that immigrants are likely to be more entrepreneurial, thus interested in small business loans. But they can also be seen as a risky proposition given that they may have no credit rating in Canada and their assets may be tied up in another country.
In Nova Scotia, the provincial government has joined with most of the province’s credit unions to operate the Immigrant Small Business Loan Program, a more targeted stream of the Nova Scotia Small Business Financing Program. Under the program, immigrants can borrow up to $500,000. What makes the loan special is that it gives credit unions the flexibility to approve more applications, explains Shaun MacIntyre, director of commercial services at Credit Union Atlantic (18,000 members, $370 million in assets).
Many of the immigrants he meets are entrepreneurial, opening small mom-and-pop restaurants and service-based businesses. That’s why, he says, this program, with its government guarantee to 90 per cent on term loans, is so important. Credit unions still analyze every loan application with a keen eye, “but this makes it easier to say ‘yes’ and that’s very important as we build bridges with newcomers to Halifax,” MacIntyre says.
Innovative networking
But even as MacIntyre lauds the loan initiative, he recognizes building a successful business sometimes takes more than hard work and funds. “Networks are so important – and that’s something new Canadians often lack,” he points out. So for the past two years, Credit Union Atlantic has sponsored a two-hour summertime working cruise on a tall ship near Halifax. The sold-out event sees 150 guests mingling aboard the vessel. About half the guests are new Canadians, with the remainder made up of employees from Credit Union Atlantic, the Immigrant Services Association of Nova Scotia and members of the business community.
“When it comes to networking, it’s great to think outside the box sometimes,” MacIntyre says. “On a cruise, you can’t show up late and you can’t leave early. Plus, the relaxed atmosphere is very conducive to making connections.”
Looking to the future
The findings of Financial Services Needs of Immigrant Communities in Canada and the United States has already led to the follow-up report, Segmenting Canadian and American Immigrant Prospects. Released in 2014, this latest strategy paper takes the conclusions of the initial report one step further, emphasizing the tremendous opportunities for growth in niche immigrant communities that are routinely ignored by large banking institutions. “Being smaller and more nimble allows credit unions to make hay with smaller numbers,” says Pigeon. “We need to seek out these financially neglected communities, understand their needs and adapt our products accordingly.”
Pigeon points to the success of Luminus Financial (4,000 members, $78 million in assets), which is highlighted in the report. Based in Toronto, the credit union has embarked on a strategy to target Ontario’s Filipino population, which sees 30,000 new immigrants arrive each year – a third of whom settle in Toronto. Remittances are a key part of the credit union’s strategy, given that immigrants send an average of $500 home each month. The report notes that “Luminus is anticipating taking five per cent of the Filipino remittance market. They expect to handle over $70 million in remittance transactions within the next couple of years. From a financial perspective this translates into $5 million in deposits, service fees of $500,000 and $175,000 in foreign exchange transactions.”
Pigeon is keen for an even deeper analysis. Still, as each report further refines our understanding of the immigrant market, the takeaway remains constant: failure to capitalize on immigrants’ ambitions and skills is a loss to them and a loss to Canada. It’s up to each credit union to know its immigrant population and understand the programs they need to succeed. ◊
![Mar2015-F1-CulturalMosaic2-Volo-[716x241]](/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Mar2015-F1-CulturalMosaic2-Volo-716x241.jpg)

